Butter vs GameTree

Pricing

Both Butter and GameTree fall in the Free price range. Butter: Free to use; you cover any activity costs. GameTree: Free with optional premium features.

Format & matching

Butter uses groups of Varies, compared to GameTree’s 1:1 and squads, and Butter relies on manual / self-select matching while GameTree uses algorithm-based matching.

How they work

Butter: Download the app and create a profile. Browse plans others have posted — anything from dinner parties to run clubs to coffee catch-ups — or host your own by setting the activity, time, and location. When someone wants to join your plan, they send a request and you decide who to accept. Show up, do the thing, and meet people who are genuinely into the same stuff. After the plan, you can stay connected through the app or just show up to the next one.

GameTree: Download the app and take a gamer personality quiz that maps your playstyle, favorite genres, and what you're looking for — competitive grinders, casual co-op partners, or just people to hang out with on Discord. Add your games and platforms (PC, Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, mobile — it covers everything). GameTree's AI matches you with compatible players based on personality psychology, not just shared game libraries. Browse your matches, send friend requests, and start chatting. There's also a Discord bot with /lfg commands for instant squad-finding in your server.

What to love

Butter: You choose the activity, so every meetup is something you actually want to do. Host-picks-guests model means more intentional, higher-quality connections. Alcohol-free plans are a first-class option, not an afterthought. Free to use with no subscription paywall. Covers a wide range of activities beyond just dining.

GameTree: AI personality matching goes deeper than just 'we both play Valorant' — it considers playstyle and social preferences. Truly cross-platform: PC, Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, and mobile all in one app. Discord bot integration lets you find teammates without leaving your server. Supports 1,300+ games from AAA shooters to tabletop RPGs. Over 1 million downloads on Android alone — large enough player pool to find matches.

Reality check

Butter: Currently limited to Melbourne — most people can't use it yet. Only four screenshots on the listing, so the app experience is a bit opaque. Success depends heavily on local user density and active hosts. No algorithmic matching — you have to browse and self-select.

GameTree: The app can feel cluttered and overwhelming on first use. Match quality varies — the AI doesn't always nail personality compatibility. 3.2-star rating on Google Play suggests inconsistent user experience. Free tier limitations push toward premium features.

Søren's take

On Butter: Butter is doing something refreshingly different: instead of matching you with strangers and hoping for the best, it lets you build plans and invite people into them. The host-selects-guests model gives you real agency, and the focus on alcohol-free and activity-based plans feels genuinely modern. The catch is that it's Melbourne-only for now, so unless you're there, you're on a waitlist. If you are in Melbourne and tired of apps that promise connection but deliver small talk, Butter is worth a serious look.

On GameTree: GameTree is trying to solve the 'I have no one to play with' problem that plagues every gamer at some point, and the personality-based approach is smarter than just matching by game title. The cross-platform support is a genuine strength — most LFG tools are siloed by platform, and GameTree doesn't care if you're on a Switch or a gaming PC. The Discord bot is a nice touch for communities that already live there. The rough edges are real, though: the app itself isn't the most polished, and the mixed reviews suggest the matching doesn't always deliver. Worth trying if you're looking for regular gaming companions, but temper your expectations on the AI magic.